|
|
How to Avoid the Carbon Offset "Gotcha" Game
For the second year in a row, the National Football League plans to offset "100%" of estimated emissions associated with the Super Bowl. Sounds pretty good, right? The NFL is taking positive climate action, from buying renewable energy certificates to replanting acreage lost to wildfires. Unlike last year, however, organizers will not tout the event as "carbon neutral," as green groups question the league's emissions calculations. Stepping back from the carbon neutral label is a smart move for the NFL, for two reasons:
- Uncertain metrics. Determining true carbon footprint is one of the toughest challenges of lifecycle assessment. Where to draw the limits? In the Super Bowl's case, are event organizers responsible to offset emissions created by transporting the attendees or just the team and staff? There's no universal agreement here. With critics playing a constant "gotcha" game, this is no time to make claims based on metrics that lack universal support.
- Uncertain benefits. Critics of carbon offsets contend that the environmental benefits are often overstated. Yet even if we assume that offset programs are legit, how can we be sure that consumers will understand their intended impact? Research by the U.K. retailer Boots finds that fewer than a third of shoppers know that a carbon footprint is linked to climate change. Labels like "carbon neutral" offer little marketing payoff if your terms are unfamiliar to consumers (they're likely to think you're stretching the truth anyway), and may make you a bigger target in the "gotcha" game (see #1).
The world of carbon measurement is still in its infancy. To keep your company's latest ad off the Greenwashing Index, I recommend that sustainable brand builders pursue these strategies:
- Work positively with multi-stakeholder groups to develop standards for carbon labeling. Aim for a scheme that consumers can understand. Nutritional labels provide a good model.
- Use trusted labels linked to carbon management, e.g. EPA's Energy Star and The Center for Resource Solution's "green-e" label for renewable energy.
- Focus on such internal and supply chain related carbon improvements as energy efficiency and use of renewable power and communicate progress to consumers and employees.
It's hardly surprising that carbon offsets are item number one on the FTC's agenda as it revamps its guidelines on green marketing. The NFL's not-quite carbon neutral Super Bowl 2008 is a case in point, raising some thorny questions that won't be answered anytime soon.
~Jacquelyn A. Ottman, President, J.Ottman Consulting and SLM Advisor
Top Stories...
Coke Braces for Water-Bottle Backlash
Come July, Coke's mailroom will be stuffed with 1 million used plastic bottles carrying anti-bottled water messages for incoming CEO Muhtar Kent. The bottles are part of an awareness campaign aimed at encouraging consumers to drink tap water. Read more...
FTC Mulls Guidelines for Carbon Offset Claims
The Federal Trade Commission is raising questions about green marketing claims surrounding carbon offsets. The commission, which is currently revamping its guidelines on environmental advertising, is concerned that theres a heightened potential for deception. Read more...
50% of Shoppers Factor Sustainability into Purchasing Decisions
Half of U.S. consumers consider at least one sustainability factor in selecting consumer packaged goods (CPG) items and choosing where to shop for those products, according to new survey. What's more, green-minded purchasing once considered a primarily youth-driven movement now appears to cut across all market segments. Read more...
Canon Introduces Green Brand, Greener Product Packaging
Office products manufacturer Canon USA will be selling its environmentally preferable printers under a new brand name. The company's PIXMA, SELPHY, and imageCLASS printer products, now to be marketed under the label "Generation Green," feature energy- and paper-saving technologies and will be shipped in resource-efficient packaging. Read more...
New Site Invites Consumers to Rate Companies' Green Ad Claims
Ads from Chevrolet, BP, and Toyota are among the first to be scrutinized on the Greenwashing Index, a new website that allows consumers to evaluate the green claims made by major advertisers. Read more...
97% of U.K. Consumers Say Companies Lack Honesty on Green
A new British Telecom survey finds that just 3% of U.K. consumers believe that businesses are "fully open and honest" about what they are really doing to operate in more sustainably, and one-third think companies exaggerate their efforts in order to score brownie points among potential customers. Read more...
More Sustainable Brands News & Tools...
 We want to hear from you! Post your comments or questions, and we'll feature the best of them here.
| | |
Forward to a Friend!
Save the Date for SB08!
Mark your calendar and plan now to join your peers at Sustainable Brands '08, where we'll explore together the latest in innovation for sustainable brands. The event will be held in California at the Hyatt Regency Monterey Resort from June 2-5, 2008.
Experts Weigh In on FTC Green Marketing Guidelines
The Federal Trade Commission is updating its guidelines for environmental advertising. How would green experts improve the system? National Public Radio's "Marketplace" asked its team of sustainability pros a.k.a. the "Greenwash Brigade" to weigh in. (Run Time: 5 Min.) Listen now...
More Brands Mediacasts...
The Blogosphere: Greenfield or Minefield?
What does the surge in interest mean for your products and brands in 2008? Join analysts from social media firm Umbria on Jan. 30 for a webinar on what consumers are saying in the blogosphere about going green and sustainability. Umbria CEO Janet Eden-Harris and senior research analyst Averill Doering will discuss brands and products in the automotive, electronics, consumer packaged goods, retail, and energy industries, explaining why some are booming and others are bombing on the sustainability topic. Register today!
Find Peers and Partners
If you haven't already joined the fastest growing online sustainable business community, create a profile now and start connecting.
Advertise on SLM!
Become a Sustainable Life Media advertiser or sponsor and reach thousands of business leaders looking for product or service solutions to
help them build their sustainability story. Click here to learn more.
Have a story you want told? Send it to us!
Solution Providers
|
|
|
|
Sustainable Life Media is home for business professionals looking to build new value and competitive advantage by innovating more sustainable processes, practices and products. We bring you top stories related to the what, who and how of environmental and social innovation, and help you connect with thought leaders, peers, partners and solutions providers that can help you quickly reach your goals.
This work is licensed under a CreativeCommons License. Copyright Sustainable Life Media Inc. 2008
|
| |
